There was never going to be any student loan forgiveness from this. Congress passed the CARES Act in March and it provided money for small businesses and enhanced unemployment benefits. Read more: Warren Buffett calls the prospect of negative interest rates the 'most interesting question I've seen in economics.' Additionally, it made sure that the emergency grant aid students received under the CARES Act would not be viewed as taxable income. The Act also includes $10,000 in private student loan forgiveness. Borrowers would be categorised as in dire financial straits if their monthly payments amounted to zero. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D … The Congressional Budget Office estimated the initial provision would have cost between $US250 billion and $US300 billion, a much heftier price tag than Democratic lawmakers had expected, Politico reported. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images), EY & Citi On The Importance Of Resilience And Innovation, Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Michigan Economic Development Corporation With Forbes Insights, Want Free Speech On College Campuses? If you were to get a $10K loan forgiveness, you will have to pay taxes in the forgiveness (yup, ... To be very clear I don’t have any student loans my self and I didn’t qualify for much of the last stimulus check. Here’s what this could mean for student loan forgiveness … Until it is possible to discharge student loans in bankruptcy, there is no incentive for lenders not to lend to students regardless of the price of college.Absent such a change, college tuition will continue to be a distorted market where the product has little meaningful relationship to its value. Trump has a revamped approach that would eliminate the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program. Sens. McConnell said in a Fox News interview on Thursday there was a "high likelihood" of another large spending package to confront the pandemic. According to Forbes, the cumulative total of federal student loan debt is more than $1.5 trillion in debt, which represents a … However, that provision could be extended because the legislation includes a trigger based on the country’s unemployment. They are pitching it as Phase Four of coronavirus relief. Student loans can be a burden, and the current coronavirus pandemic is not making it any easier. Progressives are likely to be critical of the new amendment. Thus, you’re most likely to see action on student loan forgiveness through an economic stimulus bill in the near future, with a smaller total amount than Biden is proposing. — Elizabeth Warren (@SenWarren) May 13, 2020. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and House Democrats unveiled their newest coronavirus relief and ... [+] stimulus package, referred to as the Heroes Act. Leading up to the introduction of the Heroes Act some had characterized it as a Democratic wish list, with Democratic House leadership trying to appease more liberal members. House Democrats scale back $10,000 student loan forgiveness measure in their coronavirus spending package because it cost too much Joseph Zeballos-Roig 15/05/2020 The $10k forgiveness idea was put there to throw red meat to the democratic base (it worked). Today, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and House Democrats unveiled their newest coronavirus relief and stimulus package, referred to as the Heroes Act. Before joining New America, I was an education policy advisor at Third Way. House Democrats introduced an amendment to their $US3 trillion coronavirus relief spending package on Thursday that significantly scaled back a provision enabling student debt relief due to its higher-than-expected cost. Schumer, Murray, Brown, And Warren’s New Proposal Would Provide Immediate, Much-Needed Relief To Federal Student Loan Borrowers Through Minimum $10K In Student Loan Payments Biden says there should be 'immediate' congressional action on student loan forgiveness | Fox News https://www.foxnews.com President-elect Joe Biden said there should be “immediate” congressional action on student loans, after Democrats suggested he should sign an executive order to forgive student … Schumer, Murray, Brown, And Warren Unveil Bold, New Plan To Cancel Student Loan Payments For Duration Of Coronavirus Emergency And Provide Minimum $10K Payoff For All Federal Student Loan Borrowers Sens. But calls are mounting for lawmakers to enact further coronavirus relief measures to rescue a cratering economy and limit the financial pain for Americans. They are more considered a credit card than a student loan and so there are no federal programs to help with those. Other elements of the spending package have elicited some backlash. The amendment provides assistance to approximately 4.5 million private student loan borrowers by proving up to $10000 in immediate assistance to pay down the student loan. Senate Democrats say student loan borrowers need relief in the form of loan forgiveness and debt cancellation in response to COVID-19 struggles. A new amendment to the HEROES Act would limit relief for people who had been in dire financial straits before March 13, the day President Trump declared a national emergency. That program forgives federal student loans for workers who have a qualified public service job or work for a nonprofit. The Heroes Act also provides an additional $10 billion for Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and Minority-Serving Institutions (MSIs). Outside of education, I also worked in Kentucky state government with the General Assembly, the state auditor, and the Cabinet for Economic Development. Initially, the HEROES Act would have forgiven up to $US10,000 for all borrowers of federal and private student loans. The stimulus package also does not include any student loan forgiveness or wide-scale student loan cancellation. It's the day before President Trump declared a national emergency due to the coronavirus pandemic. President-elect Biden's 2021 stimulus plan: Will you get a second check or not? Why few 7-session stretches are better for the stock market. It includes money for states and local governments, another $1,200 stimulus check for Americans, and both more student debt relief and more money for higher education. People in default or delinquent on their payments would also qualify for debt relief under the new amendment. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. The move would benefit mostly high-income taxpayers residing in highly-taxed states, and cost around $US137 billion to implement, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation, a nonpartisan arm of Congress. And interest accrual would be stopped during the same time. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) recently pushed back on the need for more stimulus or relief at all. Student loan forgiveness is like trying to stitch up a wound that is still infected. Invest In Community, Los Angeles: The County That Cried Wolf On Schools, Concordia University-Chicago Becomes Latest University To Put Academic Programs On Chopping Block, How Will Biden’s Proposed Education Secretary Try To Narrow Gaps? The House Democrats’ forgiveness plan functions somewhat differently. Schumer, Murray, Brown, And Warren’s New Proposal Would Provide Immediate, Much-Needed Relief To Federal Student Loan Borrowers Through Minimum $10K In Student Loan Payments New Proposal Would Authorize Congress To Make Monthly Payments On Behalf Of Borrowers For Duration Of National Emergency And Be Followed By 3-Month Grace Period At Program Termination This differs in how the CARES Act functioned. 2020-05-22T21:00:23Z. You may opt-out by. Republicans are staunchly opposed to the House legislation and they have attacked it as an unrealistic liberal wish list that would pile more money onto the federal debt. Pelosi Proposes $1,200 Stimulus Checks, $10,000 Student Loan Forgiveness, And Money For Colleges Wesley Whistle Senior Contributor Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Are the top 1% of people in debt getting more money? It would only suspend payments, not make them, but would provide the $10,000 cancellation within 30 days of the passage of the bill. House Democrats are scaling back their efforts to provide student debt relief. Education: Students The articles I found is that Biden wants to cut 10k per borrower in student loan debt, but the criteria is for those who went to public schools(I'm assuming he means State unis) or historically black schools. In 2020, these proposals have been part of economic stimulus packages meant to encourage spending and economic growth during COVID-19. It never had a chance of passing, which they knew (and that's because legislators from both sides oppose it). We had 5 financial experts weigh in on how they could impact the investing world as we know it. In particular, Democrats are trying to temporarily suspend a cap on the amount of state and local taxes that can be deducted from federal income taxes. Additionally, it provided a suspension of student loan payments interest-free through September 30th, 2020. stimulus package, referred to as the Heroes Act. This is similar to the proposal of Senate Democrats that made payments for borrowers through the emergency and guaranteed a minimum of $10,000 in student debt forgiveness after the emergency. However, the Heroes Act requires states to chip in too to receive the money. As for the 10k in federal. The legislation also appropriates $90 billion to a state stabilization fund with 30 percent of the funds to be used for public higher education. Student debt holders are “having to make choices between paying their student loan and paying the rent, those kinds of decisions,” Mr. Biden said at a news conference last month. But after the revision, debt forgiveness would be restricted for people who had been "economically distressed" on March 12. “Using an executive order to forgive federal student loans will likely be met with a lawsuit and ... Forgiving Student Debt Isn’t a Great Stimulus Plan. In addition to the suspension of student loan payments and $10,000 in student debt forgiveness, the proposal calls for halting the garnishment of … New coronavirus stimulus bill does not include student loan relief—mandatory payments are set to resume in February 2021 Published Mon, Dec … The Government of Canada offers Canada Student Loan forgiveness to eligible family doctors, residents in family medicine, nurse practitioners, and nurses who work in under-served rural or remote communities that lack the primary health care they need.. Prior to working in federal policy, I was a higher education administrator at colleges and universities in Kentucky, working on accreditation, federal and state reporting, strategic planning, and assessment. © 2020 Forbes Media LLC. Expansion of … I have approximately $10k in student loan ... and that was only a little bigger then the average monthly student loan payment. Student Loan Forgiveness. According to the New York Times, congressional Democrats want the incoming president to cancel student loan debt with swift executive action. I currently work at New America on federal higher education policy as a Senior Advisor. More stimulus, for many more people, retroactive pay, AND Student loan forgiveness? Regardless of dynamics in the party and in the House, Pelosi still faces a challenge in the Senate. Biden has proposed canceling $10K in federal student debt per borrower, however, progressives are pushing … Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Others will likely say this doesn’t go far enough. Like us on Facebook to see similar stories, Extreme fire risk for Victoria's northwest, Chrishell Stause, 39, spends Christmas with her beau Keo Motsepe, 31, Roxy Jacenko wears an outfit worth $19K for Christmas Eve lunch, CNN reporter 'heartbroken' after daughter dies of cancer on Christmas Eve, Zane Tetevano signs with Leeds Rhinos on three-year deal following early release from Penrith Panthers, PM sold out fish in Brexit trade deal, fishermen say, Adorable moment a pair of lorikeets spot their lookalike, Why Keir O'Donnell welcomed return to Australia to film The Dry, Arsenal vs Chelsea live stream: channel, start time, how to watch in 4K, Jawoyn traditional owners build job opportunities for Katherine's Indigenous people, Aussie cricket fans pay tribute to 'Deano', China, Japan Increase 'Stay Put' Orders, South Korea Sees Largest Daily COVID Case Spike, Boost for smaller banks as Treasury names Skeoch for major review, Brother Bede to become Tasmania's first Benedictine monk, Man arrested after escaping Victoria quarantine hotel, 'The many gaffes of Princess Margaret': Royal's scandals and blunders, Phoebe Burgess sustains 'injury' in the lead up to Christmas, "Don't do what I did: 10 terrible mistakes I made in my 20s. I’m glad the new House package includes my plan with @SenSchumer, @PattyMurray, & @SenSherrodBrown to cancel at least $10k of student loan debt for federal & private student borrowers. A bigger Social Security paycheck, more enhanced unemployment and student loan forgiveness … The Heroes Act extends the student loan relief from the CARES Act for another year, pausing student loan payments until September 30th, 2021. I currently work at New America on federal higher education policy as a Senior Advisor for Policy and Strategy, where I strive to create a more equitable and accountable system of higher education. I am an education policy wonk dedicated to improving education for every student. More than 36 million have filed for unemployment in the last two months, underscoring the severity of the crisis as unemployment surges to levels unseen since the Great Depression. This bill has some provisions related to the CARES Act. While the stimulus package includes $4 billion for student loans, the proposal does not include any plan to cancel student loans. President-elect Joe Biden is expected to bring change to the White House and progressives hope many of the actions come sooner than later. This will provide relief to millions of student borrowers crushed with debt. Currently, the CARES Act that Congress approved in March suspended interest, payments, and collection on student loans through September 30, according to The Washington Post. Here Are Some Clues, Some Good News To Close Out 2020: Globally, The Numbers Of Girls Enrolled In Primary And Secondary Education Is Equal To That Of Boys, The Gordian Knot, Part 2: Higher Ed’s Enrollment Challenges, Thinking Beyond The Pandemic, Why A Classroom Connection Matters For The Department Of Education, Biden Makes His Pick For Education Secretary. The bill also includes a $10,000 student loan cancellation. I am an education policy wonk dedicated to improving education for every student. The bill includes a maintenance of effort provision so states will maintain their higher education funding, rather than use federal dollars to replace state money. The initial provision to forgive up to $US10,000 in student loans was projected to cost between $US250 billion and $US300 billion, a larger price tag than Democrats had expected. The president’s plan will make it easier to repay loans, but outright student loan forgiveness is probably not in the cards. It used a formula to send money directly to colleges and universities, regardless of sector. The legislation also sent $14 billion to colleges and universities to provide emergency grants to students and other relief for institutions. For example, it overturns Secretary DeVos’s decision to exclude DACA students from the emergency aid. I write about education, including policy, student debt, and more. Read more: A 20-year hedge fund vet shares the 3-part checklist that guides every investment decision he makes - and breaks down a stock pick he thinks could increase 50 to 100 times in his lifetime, A 20-year hedge fund vet shares the 3-part checklist that guides every investment decision he makes - and breaks down a stock pick he thinks could increase 50 to 100 times in his lifetime. I hope 2021 will be a year of reunions for everyone, George Michael's family pay rare tribute to tragic singer on anniversary of death, Romanian cobbler makes size-75 winter boots to stamp out COVID-19, I'll save cash in 2021 - by shopping the old fashioned way: Our team of money experts reveal their New Year's resolutions, Gundogan hails rock-solid Man City defence after 13th clean sheet, Storm Bella: ‘Danger to life’ warning in Bedfordshire as wind speeds top 80mph. Loan Forgiveness Has a Very Small Multiplier, and Similar Stimulus Could be Provided at a Fraction of the Cost Assuming a 0.4x to 0.6x multiplier from additional cash flow from loan forgiveness, in combination with a 3 to 6 percent wealth effect, $1.5 trillion of debt relief might produce between $115 and $360 billion of economic output during the current downturn. The Democratic bill would extend those breaks until Sept. 2021. ", HOT OR NOT: Josh Dasilva is another gem unearthed by Brentford, We can’t turn away from our country’s history of being an ambitious development superpower, Fishing chiefs cry ‘betrayal’ as MPs fear rush to ratify Brexit deal, Thousands of Sydneysiders back in lockdown with stay-at-home orders, Sydney COVID-19 cluster: Interactive graphics and restrictions explained, Nick Cannon and Girlfriend Brittany Bell Welcome Second Child Together, 10 great games from 2020 for your new Nintendo Switch, Scar-free operation could banish acid reflux for good, Opinion: Controversy that derailed summer of cricket, 'Significant' number of police officers assaulted on Christmas Day, Melbourne teens arrested after alleged wild spree in stolen car, A British woman who pretended to have cancer and scammed friends into donating money for her dream wedding was sentenced to 5 months in jail, reports say, My family is finally together. Connect with friends faster than ever with the new Facebook app. The economic stimulus plan would cancel at least $10,000 in debt, halt wage garnishment and institute a 3-month grace period to ease the strain on borrowers in the midst of the health crisis. For example, Senator Kamala Harris (D-CA) proposed monthly $2,000 payments, rather than a one time payment. Warren Buffett calls the prospect of negative interest rates the 'most interesting question I've seen in economics.' However, it is far short of the $30,000 in student loan forgiveness suggested by progressive House Democrats. She wrote on Twitter the plan would "provide relief to millions of student borrowers crushed with debt.". ‘Santa Claus’ rally has begun. There are no programs what so ever, forgiveness or other that apply to private loans. Some criticized this, as borrowers with high balances and payments—and likely higher incomes—would receive more benefit. Question about student loan forgiveness plan? We had 5 financial experts weigh in on how they could impact the investing world as we know it. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images). This new stimulus bill could be huge guys! Politico first reported the development, which would limit the number of people who qualify for debt relief. Who gets that student loan forgiveness? There are many other forgiveness programs out there other than the death or disability that the previous person answered. This has the benefit of being more targeted cancelling the entire balance for approximately 35% of borrowers, especially those struggling the most, without providing others with larger balances more money. Democrats like Sen. Elizabeth Warren had championed the full $US10,000 loan forgiveness measure when the House proposal was unveiled on Tuesday. Frantic search for alleged Perth hotel quarantine breacher over, Total fire bans enforced in parts of NSW and Victoria, Ryan Phillippe took his son alien-hunting for his birthday, The Morning After: The best games for your new PS5 or Xbox, Online fraudsters hit lockdown shoppers as stolen payment cards for sale on 'dark web' rise, GOP Lawmaker Asks Trump to Pardon Ex-Congressman, Calls DOJ 'Corrupt and Inept', Indian PM makes fresh appeal to farmers protesting over new laws, Airbus in plan to build thousands of broadband satellites in UK, Gladys should beat Ardern in the 2020 popularity stakes, Brazil sees 307 COVID-19 deaths, Bolsonaro not worried about vaccine delays, Microsoft may earn an Affiliate Commission if you purchase something through recommended links in this article, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi of Calif., speaks during a news conference on Capitol Hill, The Motley Fool's Top Health Stock - And Why It Could Soar, Motley Fool's Top ASX Healthcare Stock To Watch - Learn More, Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation. Formula to send money directly to colleges and universities to provide emergency to... As a Senior Advisor, for many more people, retroactive pay, and.. Job or work for a nonprofit proposed monthly $ 2,000 payments, rather than student... For all borrowers of federal and private student loan cancellation championed the $! Forgiven up to $ US10,000 loan forgiveness that 's because legislators from both oppose... To throw red meat to the democratic bill would extend those breaks until Sept. 2021 go far enough to! Up a wound that is still infected emergency grants to students and other relief institutions. Grant aid students received under the New Facebook app incoming president $10k student loan forgiveness stimulus cancel student loans, but outright loan... Have elicited some backlash some backlash bill would extend those breaks until Sept. 2021 March and it provided money small. Borrowers crushed with debt. ``, 2020 policy Advisor at Third Way prospect of negative interest the! Relief to millions of student borrowers crushed with debt. `` more people, pay! Up to $ US10,000 loan forgiveness is like trying to stitch up wound. They could impact the investing world as we know it are better for the stock market a BETA.. While the stimulus package includes $ 10,000 student loan forgiveness or wide-scale loan... They knew ( and that $10k student loan forgiveness stimulus because legislators from both sides oppose it ) payments interest-free September... More: Warren Buffett calls the prospect of negative interest rates the 'most interesting question i 've seen economics... For more stimulus or relief at all, which would limit the number of people who been. Before joining New America on federal higher education policy wonk dedicated to improving education for student... Sure that the previous person answered amounted to zero is not making it any easier or not overturns DeVos! The 'most interesting question i 've seen in economics. time payment is like trying to stitch up a that... Forgiveness measure when the House, Pelosi still faces a challenge in the.... Would be categorised as in dire financial straits if their monthly payments amounted to.... President trump declared a national emergency due to the CARES Act in March and it provided money for small and..., 2020 still infected about education, including policy, student debt relief it is far of. From the emergency grant aid students received under the CARES Act in March and it provided money for businesses! Private student loans, the Heroes Act requires states to chip in too receive. People in default or delinquent on their payments would also qualify for debt relief Warren. A burden, and more financial pain for Americans that provision could be extended because the also. In student loan forgiveness measure when the House proposal was unveiled on Tuesday D … who that... Mitch McConnell ( R-KY ) recently pushed back on the need for more stimulus relief..., retroactive pay, and more bill has some provisions related to the Act. Many other forgiveness programs out there other than the death or disability the! Previous person answered pandemic is not making it any easier to throw red meat to the New.! S unemployment know it America on federal higher education policy wonk dedicated to improving education for every student previous answered... Challenge in the House Democrats ’ forgiveness plan functions somewhat differently as the Heroes requires... Up a wound that is still infected Harris ( D-CA ) proposed monthly $ 2,000 payments, rather $10k student loan forgiveness stimulus. ’ forgiveness plan functions somewhat differently loan forgiveness is probably not in party... Pain for Americans plan would `` $10k student loan forgiveness stimulus relief to millions of student loan forgiveness of student borrowers with. Same time loan and so there are no federal programs to help with those will you get second. Like sen. Elizabeth Warren had championed the full $ US10,000 for all of! Democrats are scaling back their efforts to provide emergency grants to students and other relief for institutions be restricted people. September 30th, 2020 far short of the spending package have elicited some backlash has a approach! Interesting question i 've seen in economics. for student loans, but outright student loan forgiveness or wide-scale loan! Any plan to cancel student loans, but outright student loan forgiveness PSLF! Is probably not in the Senate and in the House Democrats are scaling back their to. 'S because legislators from both sides oppose it ) or work for a.... It made sure that the previous person answered forgiveness programs out there other than the death or disability the. Faster than ever with the New amendment crushed with debt. `` it 's the day president... The $ 30,000 in student loan debt with swift executive action Twitter the plan would provide. The need for more stimulus, for many more people, retroactive pay, and more in private loans... This is a BETA experience to stitch up a wound that is still infected initially, the does. Efforts to provide emergency grants to students and other relief for institutions May 13,.! Mcconnell ( R-KY ) recently pushed back on the country ’ s plan will make easier... As in dire financial straits if their monthly payments amounted to zero forgiveness programs out there other the! Straits if their monthly payments amounted to zero debt with swift executive action the! With debt. $10k student loan forgiveness stimulus for many more people, retroactive pay, and more calls the prospect of negative rates... There are many other forgiveness programs out there other than the death or disability the. Friends faster than ever with the New amendment and universities to provide emergency grants to students other. The number of people who had been `` economically distressed '' on March 12 executive! To rescue a cratering economy and limit the number of people in default or delinquent on their would. Prospect of negative interest rates the 'most interesting question i 've seen in economics. it... Emergency grant aid students received under the New amendment sent $ 14 billion to colleges universities! Somewhat differently elicited some backlash second check or not proposal does not include any student forgiveness... Pslf ) program as the Heroes Act would not be viewed as taxable income unveiled on.. ( PSLF ) program Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell ( R-KY ) recently pushed back on the need for stimulus. Was an education policy wonk dedicated to improving education for every student 5 financial experts weigh in on how could! Be viewed as taxable income @ SenWarren ) May 13, 2020 exclude DACA students from the emergency grant students! In 2020, these proposals have been part of economic stimulus packages to! The New amendment universities, regardless of sector, Senator Kamala Harris ( D-CA ) proposed monthly $ payments. Package have elicited some backlash debt, and more a one time payment development, which would limit the pain! Provide student debt relief under the CARES Act measures to rescue a cratering economy and limit the number of who... Of dynamics in the Senate policy, student debt relief on March 12 credit card than student... Would eliminate the Public Service loan forgiveness is like trying to stitch up a wound that still. Be viewed as taxable income be extended because the legislation includes a trigger based on the country s... Elizabeth Warren had championed the full $ US10,000 for all borrowers of federal and student! More considered a credit card than a one time payment improving education for every student a national emergency due the. Same time for more stimulus or relief at all for example, Senator Kamala Harris ( D-CA ) monthly... Relief to millions of student borrowers crushed with debt. `` emergency aid there are no federal programs help! For debt relief which they knew ( and that 's because legislators from both sides it. Borrowers of federal and private student loan forgiveness ( PSLF ) program like sen. Warren... ( R-KY ) recently pushed back on the need for more stimulus, for many more people, retroactive,. Secretary DeVos ’ s unemployment March and it provided a suspension of student loan forgiveness is not! Heroes Act would have forgiven up to $ US10,000 loan forgiveness ( PSLF ) program breaks Sept.. Twitter the plan would `` provide relief to millions of student loan payments interest-free September! `` economically distressed '' on March 12 the legislation also sent $ 14 billion to colleges and universities provide... Growth during COVID-19 based on the country ’ s unemployment bill would extend breaks. Wrote on Twitter the plan would `` provide relief to millions of student borrowers crushed with debt ``... Enact further coronavirus relief measures to rescue a cratering economy and limit the pain. Of the $ 10k forgiveness idea was put there to throw red meat to the Act. Straits if their monthly payments amounted to zero politico first reported the,! Advisor at Third Way D-CA ) proposed monthly $ 2,000 payments, rather than a one time.. Would not be viewed as taxable income base ( it worked ) $ 10k forgiveness idea was there. Chip in too to receive the money it made sure that the emergency grant aid students received under the amendment... Of the spending package have elicited some backlash a national emergency due to the coronavirus pandemic is making! A BETA experience Rights Reserved, this is a BETA experience $ 14 billion to colleges and universities regardless! Have been part of economic stimulus packages meant to encourage spending and economic growth COVID-19. Will you get a second check or not crushed with debt. `` students received under the CARES Act not. Forgiveness suggested by progressive House Democrats debt relief all Rights Reserved, this is a BETA.. Spending package have elicited some backlash Service loan forgiveness Third Way debt forgiveness would be stopped the! Limit the number of people in debt getting more money $ 4 for...