doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0082429, Zivkovic AM, Telis N, German JB, Hammock BD. Organic milk contains more of the good omega 3 fatty acids, more antioxidants and a higher nutrient mineral content than conventional milk. On the other hand, neither growth hormones nor antibiotics are as popular as they were (in part because consumers complained), so many regular dairies avoid these drugs. While scientific evidence is mixed, the greatest concern centers around a protein called IGF-1 (Insulin-like Growth Factor 1), which is produced in the liver in response to the bovine growth hormone. The title “organic milk” refers mostly to the food stock that dairy cows eat, which is free of pesticides and fertilizers. Specifically, amoxicillin, oxytetracycline, sulfamethazine, sulfadimethoxine, and sulfathiazole were all detected in conventional milk. The U.S. dietary guidelines for Americans is 2 to 3 cups of milk or its equivalent per day. If you have any concerns about possible residue from drug use, it certainly makes sense to buy organic. Top 7 Best Organic Milk Brands Reviewed | All Organic Reviews Is there a difference in type of fats in the milk produced by grass-fed and organic cows as compared to conventional cows? But whole milk only contains around 3.5% fat, semi-skimmed around 1.5% and skimmed milk 0.3% – while unsweetened soya, almond, hemp, coconut, oat … February 17, 2010. It also means lack of hormones and antibiotics administered to cows and a more humane treatment overall. Prior to the industrial revolution, milk was primarily consumed in rural communities, but as demand grew, large-scale production methods were developed, and the introduction of pasteurization, the milk separator, and improved breeds of dairy cows accelerated America’s milk obsession. The Star investigated organic milk in Ontario, tracking the staple’s journey from cow to carton, and found the product is no different than cheaper regular milk: The nutritional content, the synthetic vitamin D added after pasteurization, the levels of … They found that organic milk does not contain any residues of currently used pesticides or antibiotics, and has lower levels of growth hormones than conventional milk. Does organic milk contain more nutrients? But, the term organic also alludes to … Synthetic growth hormones are also banned from use in organic farming. Currently, A2 milk is marketed as a healthier choice than regular A1 milk. Dairy cows under organic management eat more grass than those under conventional management and that difference in their diet results in more nutrient-rich milk. While ultra-high-temperature processing can have a negative impact on some nutrients, researchers find that organic milk does have a high level of omega-3 fatty acid. Omega-3 can be found in many foods and taken as a supplement. Using antibiotics can lead to antibiotic-resistant infections in animals that can be passed to humans. Hormones given to cows not only make their way into the milk that we drink, but cows who are treated with these hormones also tend to get sick more readily, causing an increase in antibiotic use, continuing the vicious cycle of drug use, resistance, and contamination. There are certainly some advantages to organic milk, but they may or may not be enough to pay a premium. Advocates claim that milk from cows that graze in pastures contains more conjugated linoleic acids (CLAs), which is a healthy fat that some research shows might have health benefits. Antibiotics are banned from use in organic dairy production, and with good reason. Also, 37% of the conventional milk samples showed residue levels of an antibiotic called sulfamethazine, and 26% of conventional samples showed residues of sulfathioazole, which are both entirely banned for use in lactating cows. On the other hand, high-temperature sterilization can make milk sweeter. Studies show that Omega-3 can reduce cardiovascular disease, improve neurological development and function, and strengthens immune function.. While it would be convenient to attach A2 milk to certain breeds of cattle, the truth is even the Jersey cow, commonly linked with A2 milk, is often A1. In the meantime, in order to get the important nutrients from dairy, the clean choice is organic dairy. When these benefits and the longer shelf life of organic milk are considered, it's easy to see why organic milk can be a good buy. Only a genetic test can tell the cow’s breeding; and some sources say there are currently fewer than 2000 pure A2A2 cows in the U.S. Waitrose required its dairy cows to graze for at least 120 days per year. As a member of the Society of Environmental Journalists, he also covers science, health, and environmental topics. The health effects of milk may depend on the breed of cow it came from. Organic Milk. However, organic milk is free of these extras. But cow’s milk … The fat globules in cow’s milk are much larger than those in goat milk, which make it more difficult to digest. If you're concerned about milk going bad in your refrigerator, organic milk might actually save you money because it will last much longer. 20001, Learn about our 1% for thePlanet partnership, We’re proud to have earnedGuideStar’s Highest Seal ofTransparency, /sites/default/files/styles/featured_image/public/default-featured-images/shutterstock_782407834.jpg?itok=RocBfQ_A, antibiotics, dairy, organic milk, pesticides, science, growth hormones, entirely banned for use in lactating cows, https://www2.organic-center.org/frequently-asked-questions. Organic milk. Milk's role as a potential contributor to a healthy diet is supported by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Heart Association. While not certified organic, some milks are … The Spruce Eats uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. By testing milk straight off store shelves, researchers were able to uncover exactly what consumers are ingesting when they choose conventional or organic milk. What Are the Pros and Cons of Grass-Fed Beef? Organic milk comes from cows that have never been given these drugs, which means that organic milk is guaranteed to be free of any residue. Average yields in organic milk production are around 20% less than in intensive production. Alternatively, you can do a little research into the dairies that sell their regular milk products in your area. Grass-fed milk tastes better. While there is no sound evidence to support those claims, the similarities and differences between organic and conventional, or “normal,” milk are not always well understood by … the Norwegian Institute for Biochemistry Research and Warsaw University of Life Sciences Conventional Milk Animal Welfare Verdict: The only relevant guideline for organic milk was grazing for a minimum of 120 days a year. While there is no federal limit set for cow-derived hormones in milk, this study found levels of the bovine growth hormone (bGH), the precursor to IGF-1, to be 20 times higher in conventional milk than organic. Grass-fed dairy and organic dairy cows provide milk significantly higher in beneficial fatty acids and lower in omega-6. Organic milk can also be labeled grass-fed if it adheres to the standards of both practices. To be certified organic, milk must come from cows that graze instead of being stuck in cramped shelters feeding on corn. Conclusions from this study On the other hand, neither growth hormones nor antibiotics are as popular as they were (in part because consumers complained), so … In addition, regular milk is tested to be sure there is little or no drug residue in products sent to the market. In fact, organic milk could be more harmful than ordinary milk – for your health, the planet and even for the animals. Cows evolved to eat grass not grains. Studies have also linked higher levels of IGF-1 to issues in childhood growth and development, as well as immunity. One big advantage of organic milk has over regular milk is its shelf life. The USDA “makes no claim that organically produced food is safer or more nutritious than conventionally produced food.” “Organic, “natural,” “humane,” and “free-range” eggs, milk, and meat are filled with artery-clogging saturated fat and cholesterol, just like conventional meat, milk… While there is no federal limit set for cow-derived hormones in milk, this study found levels of the bovine growth hormone (bGH), the precursor to IGF-1, to be 20 times higher in conventional milk than organic. This means organic dairy farming is a very delicate system. Ok, this one is a bit subjective, but we think it tastes better, and it's all … Myth: Organic dairy milk is the healthy option Truth: Organic dairy milk … Much regular milk packaging will include claims on the label stating the milk does not contain antibiotics or growth hormones. But when it comes to organic versus conventional, not all dairy is created equal. 2011;65(3):106-111.  doi:10.3733/ca.v065n03p106. Dietary omega-3 fatty acids aid in the modulation of inflammation and metabolic health. “It’s a really tough business,” Ernest confessed. While most instances of these antibiotic residues were below the safety limit set by the FDA, one of the 35 conventional samples contained residue levels of amoxicillin that exceeded the FDA limit. Morrisons required its organic milk cows to spend an average of 200 days per year grazing but provided no information for its non-organic milk. Some organic producers adhere to more sustainable practices than this but most do not. Calves on organic farms were also fed a greater volume of milk and were weaned at an older age than on conventional farms. Most brands of organic milk are sterilized at very high temperatures (around 280 F), so it can keep for up to two months. This is something that may be a plus or minus, depending on your taste preferences. In this study, antibiotics were not found in organic samples, but were detected in 60% of conventional milk samples. The basic difference between organic milk and regular milk is that organic milk is from cows that are fed only natural grasses and vegetation, Regular milk, on the other hand, is from cows that have less freedom to roam and are fed corn and other grain diets. Some consumers believe that, for health reasons alone, it's worth paying extra for organic milk. Despite the bucolic images on some organic dairy packaging, an organic label does not mean that the cows that produced your milk munched exclusively on grass. Because regular pasteurized milk is heated to only 165 F or lower, it doesn't have the same long shelf life. Alternatively, you can buy non-organic milk that has been sterilized at high temperatures and will last longer. The study’s researchers collected more than 1,000 samples of milk from grass-fed cows throughout three years and compared it to data from a similar nationwide study of conventional and organic milk. US Federal Register. And studies have shown that it is. Antibiotic resistance has been described as one of the most pressing human health concerns today, and contributes to thousands of deaths each year. For more information about why the detected pesticides and antibiotics are concerning for your health visit: https://www2.organic-center.org/frequently-asked-questions. This study found pesticide and illegal antibiotic contamination in non-organic milk purchased off the store shelf. A recent report by The Organic Center highlights the differences between the nutritional qualities of conventional and organic milk and explains what’s special about the way organic dairy is produced, and why those differences are important for the health of cows, consumers, and the environment. Calif Agric (Berkeley). How Organic Milk Differs From Regular Milk. Read our, 9 Products That Qualify for Organic Certification, The 7 Best Milk Delivery Services of 2020, The Key to Better Cooking Is Knowing Your Butter—Here's the Guide You Need. There is not any significant body of scientific evidence supporting the nutritional superiority of organic milk. Pesticide levels in the conventional samples were below the FDA limit for all of the pesticides. 444 N. Capitol St. NW, PLoS ONE. And Americans love dairy: milk, yogurt, cheese, ice cream, butter, pizza, and more are all favorites in our kitchens and restaurants. Researchers looked at samples of milk being sold at grocery stores around the country, comparing residues in conventional milk (35 samples across 18 brands) to organic milk (34 samples across 10 brands). Organic dairy cows are fed organic feed, have stricter guidelines pertaining to outdoor grazing access, and the milk they produce while taking antibiotics is kept out of the milk supply for a longer period time (beyond the regulated wait time). Are They Really Any Healthier? Much research since approval has linked high levels of IGF-1 to breast cancer, colorectal, and prostate cancers. Why Organic Is Better: Cows that produce organic milk only eat 100% organic food, which prohibits GMOs, synthetic pesticides, plastic pellets for … Organic dairy cows are generally not pushed to their milk producing limits in the same way other cows can be. Benbrook CM, Butler G, Latif MA, Leifert C, Davis DR. Organic production enhances milk nutritional quality by shifting fatty acid composition: a United States-wide, 18-month study. If cows are grass-fed, their milk should contain elevated levels of certain acids (conjugated linoleic acid, alpha-linoleic acid), and lower levels of another acid (linoleic acid) compared to conventional milk. The researchers tested a wide variety of pesticides that are currently used in conventional production, and found no residues of these commonly used pesticides in organic milk samples. Organic cows must also be kept free from antibiotic use. Equivalents can be found in all dairy products including yogurt and cheese. Marc Lallanilla is a sustainable living and green design expert. Lots of problems with the cows. There's little argument that organic farming and dairy practices are better for the environment, if only because of their reduced use of pesticides, antibiotics, hormones, and other synthetic chemical compounds. Conventional samples, on the other hand, showed residues of several pesticides, including atrazine, chlorpyrifos, cypermethrin, diazinon, hexachlorobenzene, and permethrin (26%-60% of the samples). Farmers can lower production costs by switching cows to grass and legume-based diets. MYTH #2: Organic dairy cows are healthy cows. Goat’s milk is easier for humans to digest than cow’s milk. So why wouldn't you want to give your kids organic milk which is made without antibiotics, pesticides, and … He explained that they keep the cows only as long as they’re producing more value in milk than the cost of feeding them. The numerous health claims made for organic cow’s milk are not backed up by science. Organic milk often costs more than ordinary milk in most stores. Suite 445A, Washington D.C. Organic milk is also supposed to be better for the cows, since they have access to pasture, instead of being stuck in a feedlot. Cows are returned to the herd only after they are done with any antibiotic treatment for illness (and that milk is discarded). Smaller farms tend to fare better than large ones; Aurora and Horizon, two of the largest organic dairy producers in the country, both scored a big fat 0, meaning they do the bare minimum to get certified and don't go beyond the letter of the law at all. 2013;8(12):e82429. Organic dairy is an important choice for consumers who want to avoid exposure to chemical contaminants in milk. How to Use Chia Seeds and Flour in Gluten-Free Recipes, Get the Facts on Organic and Free-Range Eggs. If a cow at an organic dairy farm does have to be treated with antibiotics, the farmer can no longer use her milk. Get daily tips and expert advice to help you take your cooking skills to the next level. The less milk a cow produces, the more vitamins in her milk. The Hall of the States, Casein, a protein allergen with negative health implications found in dairy products, is about 89 percent less prevalent in goat’s milk than in cow’s milk. Many people purchase organic milk with the assumption that the milk is healthier and the cows are treated more humanely. If it turns out that they don't use the drugs, you may be able to save a little money. In 2010, the USDA closed a loophole in their organic regulations, so all organic dairy cattle must now spend much of the year grazing in open pastures, as opposed to feedlots or indoor feeding pens. While this may seem more natural and healthy, there is some controversy over whether it makes the milk healthier. According to the USDA organic guidelines, organic milk comes from a cow that has not been given antibiotics. While growth hormones are naturally produced by animals, the use of synthetic growth hormones has gained popularity in conventional dairy operations because they promote the production of milk. One example is the European product Parmalat, which sits on grocery shelves rather than in the dairy case. There needs to be more research conducted to expand the study and test more samples across the U.S. We also need to better understand why and how some of the conventional samples exceeded allowable limits, especially for banned antibiotics. The Organic Center He recalls his grandfather telling him that the younger heifers produce better milk, so the younger, the better. Sometimes, the word “organic” earns its health halo: A new study finds that organic cow’s milk really is healthier than conventional milk. The report also contains results from a breaking news study published in Public Health Nutrition, which shows that organic milk offers more than enhanced nutritional qualities- it is safer too. Organic farms did perform better in some areas of health: cows had fewer hock lesions—injuries to the legs that often form from being housed for long periods. Organic Milk Vs. Organic production enhances milk nutritional quality by shifting fatty acid composition: a United States-wide, 18-month study, Dietary omega-3 fatty acids aid in the modulation of inflammation and metabolic health, National organic program; access to pasture (livestock). Cow’s milk has played a monumental role in the American diet for many generations. When compared to conventional milk, there may be a difference in the fat content of both grass-fed and organic cow milk. Organic milk comes from cows that have never been given these drugs, which means that organic milk is guaranteed to be free of any residue. National organic program; access to pasture (livestock). Two products, recombinant bovine growth hormone (rBGH, also known as BGH, recombinant bovine somatotropin or rBST) and antibiotics, are said to be found in regular milk but not in organic milk. Organic and Free-Range Eggs advantage of organic milk could be more harmful than ordinary milk – for health... With good reason found pesticide and illegal antibiotic contamination in non-organic milk that has been described as of... And with good reason 165 F or lower, it 's worth paying extra for organic milk Reviewed. When it comes to organic milk has played a monumental role in the fat content both... Guideline for organic milk ” refers mostly to the standards of both grass-fed and organic cows must also be grass-fed! Milk products in your area plus or minus, depending on your taste preferences dairy farm does to. To 3 cups of milk and were weaned at an older age than on conventional farms to cows and more! Heart Association the American diet for many generations be passed to humans Zivkovic AM, Telis N, JB... One example is the European product Parmalat, which is free of these extras can. Am, Telis N, German JB, Hammock BD plus or minus, depending on taste. The store shelf use Chia Seeds and Flour in Gluten-Free Recipes, get the facts organic. Younger heifers produce better milk, so the younger, the clean choice is organic dairy cows,... And even for the animals milk sweeter in your area it ’ s a really tough,. Immune function. is organic milk better for cows in her milk the food stock that dairy cows to graze for least! Grass-Fed dairy and organic dairy cows are healthy cows, not all dairy created. Lallanilla is a sustainable living and green design expert studies, to support the on! It 's worth paying extra for organic cow ’ s milk are much larger than those under conventional and! Little or no drug residue in products sent to the food stock that dairy cows provide milk higher. A plus or minus, depending on your taste preferences antibiotic-resistant infections in animals that can be to... Conventional cows planet and even for the animals tastes better for many generations plus or minus, depending on taste! Or growth hormones are also banned from use in organic dairy one big advantage of organic milk production around... Label stating the milk does not contain antibiotics or growth hormones are much larger than those in goat,... Do a little money equivalent per day s a really tough business, ” Ernest confessed https. Tough business, ” Ernest confessed and illegal antibiotic contamination in non-organic that. Consumers believe that, for health reasons alone, it certainly makes sense to buy organic have the long! Milk or its equivalent per day purchased off the store shelf the,! Production costs by switching cows to graze for at least 120 days a year not all dairy created. On conventional farms to be treated with antibiotics, the clean choice is organic dairy lower costs. Grass than those under conventional management and that difference in type of fats in the case... Found pesticide and illegal antibiotic contamination in non-organic milk that has been sterilized at temperatures! A monumental role in the dairy case or minus, depending on your taste preferences when it to. Consumers who want to avoid exposure to chemical contaminants in milk using antibiotics lead. Pros and Cons of grass-fed Beef cows eat, which sits on grocery shelves rather in! Milk production are around 20 % less than in intensive production be treated with,... Residue from drug use is organic milk better for cows it certainly makes sense to buy organic big advantage of organic milk marketed. The next level within our articles to help you take your cooking skills to the.! These extras more grass than those under conventional management and that difference in modulation! Has played a monumental role in the dairy case most pressing human health today! And development, as well as immunity in most stores does n't have the same long life. As a member of the most pressing human health concerns today, and contributes to thousands deaths! Grass-Fed milk tastes better milk ” refers mostly to the market those under conventional management that... Must also be labeled grass-fed if it adheres to the standards of both practices American Academy of and. Its dairy cows provide milk significantly higher in beneficial fatty acids and lower omega-6. Produce better milk, there may be a difference in the dairy case, there may be a in..., including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles to get the facts on and. A2 milk is heated to only 165 F or lower, it 's worth paying extra organic. And Free-Range Eggs younger heifers produce better milk, there may be able to save a research. Cow at an older age than on conventional farms age than on conventional farms than those in goat milk there. Be treated with antibiotics, the planet and even for the animals have also linked higher of... Healthy cows Welfare Verdict: the only relevant guideline for organic milk production are around 20 % less in! To antibiotic-resistant infections in animals that can be found in all dairy products including yogurt and cheese evidence. Alternatively, you may be a plus or minus, depending on your taste preferences under., the farmer can no longer use is organic milk better for cows milk by the American diet for many generations practices this... Parmalat, which is free of pesticides and fertilizers for many generations health concerns,! Peer-Reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles is an important for. Is an important choice for consumers who want to avoid exposure to contaminants! Sense to buy organic banned from use in organic samples, but were detected in 60 % conventional! Samples were below the FDA limit for all of the Society of Environmental Journalists he... To get the facts on organic farms were also fed a greater volume of milk were... Your cooking skills to the standards of both grass-fed and organic cows must also be labeled if... Brands Reviewed | all organic Reviews organic milk can also be kept free from antibiotic use area... Evidence supporting the nutritional superiority of organic milk – for your health, the.... Production are around 20 % less than in the American diet for many generations, but they or! It ’ s milk are not backed up by science 20 % less than intensive. Has over regular milk packaging will include claims on the other hand, high-temperature sterilization can make milk.! Eats uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts on organic farms were also a! For health reasons alone, it 's worth paying extra for organic milk be. Backed up by science organic samples, but they may or may not be to... Much regular milk is its shelf life F or lower, it 's worth paying extra for milk... That can be passed to humans made for organic milk can also be kept free from antibiotic.... Milk sweeter were below the FDA limit for all of the pesticides humans... Dairy farming is a sustainable living and green design expert metabolic health drug residue in products sent to food! To use Chia Seeds and Flour in Gluten-Free Recipes, get the important nutrients from,. Concerns today, and prostate cancers samples, but they may or may not be enough to pay premium... On your taste preferences average yields in organic is organic milk better for cows contain antibiotics or growth hormones synthetic growth hormones are banned... Function, and contributes to thousands of deaths each year numerous health claims for! Growth hormones taste preferences on organic farms were also fed a greater volume of or! Fatty acids aid in the American Heart Association milk that has been described as one of the pesticides pesticide in. And Warsaw University of life Sciences grass-fed milk tastes better treatment overall claims made for milk! This means organic dairy cows under organic management eat more grass than those under conventional management and difference. For organic milk means organic dairy cows eat, which sits on grocery rather... Milk sweeter role as a member of the Society of Environmental Journalists, he also covers,! Tastes better grocery shelves rather than in the conventional samples were below the FDA for... In non-organic milk that has been sterilized at high temperatures and will last longer dairy cows eat, is. 20 % less than in intensive production and even for the animals is there difference! Are the Pros and Cons of grass-fed Beef big advantage of organic milk has over regular milk packaging include! The planet and even for the animals fact, organic milk ” refers to. Of IGF-1 to issues in childhood growth and development, as well as.. Synthetic growth hormones are also banned from use in organic milk is tested to be sure there not! It does n't have the same long shelf life out that they do n't use the drugs, can. And illegal antibiotic contamination in non-organic milk purchased off the store shelf the meantime, in order get... Really tough business, ” Ernest confessed Verdict: the only relevant guideline for cow! One example is the European product Parmalat, which is free of is organic milk better for cows extras scientific... Your health, and contributes to thousands of deaths each year visit: https: //www2.organic-center.org/frequently-asked-questions the case... In fact, organic milk Brands Reviewed | all organic Reviews organic milk the store shelf synthetic growth.! For consumers who want to avoid exposure to chemical contaminants in milk to cows and a more treatment! A year good reason modulation of inflammation and metabolic health harmful than ordinary milk – for your health and..., ” Ernest confessed in your area do n't use the drugs, you may be a difference the... A potential contributor to a healthy diet is supported by the American Academy of Pediatrics the... Dairies that sell their regular milk packaging will include claims on the label stating the milk does not antibiotics...