The J&K IoA has been the subject of one of the biggest and long drawn controversies in independent India. The Nizam surrendered after four days, and agreed to Indian demands. I/33/47, Year 1947. However, eventually some of them signed instruments of merger, to form larger administrative units such as the Matsya Union, Vindhya Pradesh, PEPSU, Travancore and Cochin etc. The draft of the Standstill Agreement was formulated on 3rd June 1947 by the political department of the British Indian government and stated that all Tabling of the IoAs in the Constituent Assembly (Legislative). The Instrument of Accession signed by Maharaja Hari Singh has become the object of a never-ending controversy, unlike similar accession instruments signed by other princely states. See more. The Indian Independence Act of 1947 had put forth the legal basis for the departure of the British from the subcontinent, and guaranteed Partition. P-I/20/47, Year 1947. Until I began my research on this subject, I had also harboured a similar misconception. Legal proceedings are required to be issued within certain timeframes under the Limitation Act 1980, but, if for some reason it is not appropriate or cost effective to issue the proceedings within that timeframe the parties can agree, through a standstill agreement, not to issue them and that if they subsequently need to, they will not be … The Instrument of Accession referred to in document (c), a letter which as we have seen was probably drafted by Indian officials prior to being shown to the Maharajah, may never have existed, and can hardly have existed when the letter was being prepared.”:, accessed on 22 October, 2016. Interestingly, while the IoAs and the standstill agreements in the case of Mysore, Manipur, Tehri Garhwal and Udaipur indicate that they were drawn up in the names of the rulers of those states and the Dominion of India, in the case of J&K, both documents are drawn up in the name of the Jammu and Kashmir State. 11(8)-PR/47 on the subject: Kashmir Affairs – Accession of Kashmir State to the Dominion of India. Sub-section 6 of the new Section 6 required the laying of copies of the Instrument of Accession on the table of the dominion legislature soon after they were accepted by the governor general. I walked towards the shelves situated at the end of the hall, my shoes squeaking across the extra smooth flooring, butterflies fluttering in my stomach. [1] While the Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the MHA did not bother to reply to my request, my RTI application was transferred to the National Archives only after I submitted the first appeal to the appellate authority in MHA. In his judgment, Mostyn appeared to state that the whole idea of standstill agreements was invalid, and that it was not for the parties to a case to override deadlines set by statute. The last time I got as excited was a few days earlier, when I spotted a reference to this document in the Index of 1,847 treaties and agreements transferred by the Central government to the National Archives for safe keeping.[3]. It was accepted by Pakistan on 13 September. The Backstory of Article 370: A True Copy of J&K’s Instrument of Accession, website of Pakistan’s Ministry of External Affairs, Kashmir in Conflict: India, Pakistan and the Unending War, http://www.jammu-kashmir.com/documents/instrument_of_accession.html, website of the Commissioner of Customs, Excise and Service Tax, Hydebarad-IV, The Story of the Integration of the Indian States, Kashmir Accession Document Shrouded in False Myths. [8], Soon the Nizam came under pressure from Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (Ittehad), the Muslim nationalist party that was active in the state, and backed off from the agreement. [1], Both the draft agreements were presented to the Chamber of Princes on 25 July. The standstill agreement usually specifies that junior lenders are prohibited from taking action for up to six months after the borrower goes into default. In response, the Indian government took the position that it would sign standstill agreements with only those states that acceded. The then yuvaraj of J&Km who exercised all powers delegated to him by the Maharaja, issued a proclamation on November 25, 1949 stating that the soon-to-be-adopted Constitution of India would govern the relations between J&K and the Union only to such extent as its provisions would apply to J&K. He works with the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative. Article 306a – which would later become Article 370 – laid down the terms and conditions of this relationship. The remaining powers were retained by them just as the maharaja of J&K had sought to do. In all these cases, the standstill agreements were signed by the rulers’ subordinates. Standstill agreement. M-II/1/47, Year 1947. [21], Incorporation treaty for Princely states into India and Pakistan, Menon, The Story of Integration of the Indian States (1956), Kamat, Border incidents, internal disorder and the nizam's claim (2007), Raghavan, War and Peace in Modern India (2010), Benichou, From Autocracy to Integration (2000), Chandra, Mukherjee & Mukherjee, India since Independence (2008), "Border incidents, internal disorder and the, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Standstill_agreement_(India)&oldid=980477365, Short description is different from Wikidata, All Wikipedia articles written in Indian English, Articles to be expanded from September 2016, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 26 September 2020, at 19:07. Despite several efforts I could not locate on the Internet reliable bibliographical information about this work attributed to Prof. Lamb. [8] On the morning of 27 October, Qasim Rizvi, the leader of Ittehad, organised a massive demonstration of several thousand activists to blockade the delegation's departure. [16] V. P. Menon has stated that Nizam and his advisers viewed the agreement as providing breathing space during which the Indian troops would be withdrawn and the state could build up its position so as to assert independence. After multiple rounds of negotiations, the government of India delivered an ultimatum on 31 August 1948, demanding a ban on the razakars and the stationing of Indian troops in the state to keep law and order. In all five cases, the standstill agreements were signed by Shri V. P. Menon on behalf of the Dominion of India. Such nitpicking does not help informed debate on the subject. Given the trying circumstances in 1947 and the sheer number of documents that had to be signed from across the country, such discrepancies are highly likely to occur, especially in a newly created department that was short staffed and had set a near impossible deadline for itself to secure the integration of India. This STANDSTILL AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”) is made and entered into this 3rd day of March 2004 by and between Ask Jeeves, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the “Company”) and (the “Stockholder”). They seem to remain in the custody of the Union home ministry. The form of the agreement was bilateral between a dominion and a princely state. The author has in his possession a legitimately obtained photocopy of Copy No. and finally accepted the scheme of administration laid down by the new Constitution. Interestingly, the provisions under Article 370 were intended to be transitional and temporary in nature. Pakistan had entered into a Standstill Agreement with the Maharaja of Jammu and Kashmir on August 12, 1947. [18] See the title of both documents in the images accompanying this article. In fact, my inspiration to seek copies of the IoAs including that of J&K came from a reading of three pieces of legislation, namely, The Government of India Act, 1935 (GoI Act), the India Independence Act, 1947 and The India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947. While researching the IoAs and declassified files relating to J&K in the National Archives, I came across multiple files containing the correspondence between Ms. Sarabhai and the Government of India, particularly in relation to the abducted women and children after the partition of the sub-continent. Page 3 contains the list of subjects on which the Dominion Legislature’s powers to make laws applicable to J&K were accepted by the Maharaja by virtue of this accession instrument. Subsequently, Noorani[19] and others have extensively dwelt upon the manner in which the protection provided by Article 370 was eroded from the very beginning. It provided that all the administrative arrangements then existing between the British Crownand the state would continue unaltered between the signatory dominion (India or Pakistan) and the princely state, until new arrange… sign Standstill Agreements with both the Dominions. The agreement provided that all the administrative arrangements of 'common concern' then existing between the British Crown and any particular signatory state would continue unaltered between the signatory dominion (India or Pakistan) and the state until new arrangements were made. Interestingly, Mr. Noorani dedicates Article 370 to Ms. Mridula Sarabhai. October 26, 2016 marked the 70th anniversary of the accession of Jammu and Kashmir to India. Agents would be exchanged between Hyderabad and India. [11] National Archives Register No. IoAs signed by the several other princely States contain a standstill agreement between them and the Dominion of India as annexures.[9]. [13] The agreement was signed by the Nizam on 29 November 1947. The Standstill agreement was to remain in force for a period of one year. Legal definition of standstill agreement: an agreement providing for the preservation of the status quo for a specified or indefinite period: as. On 22 October 1947, Pakistani backed tribesmen from the western districts of the State and Pushtoon tribesmen from the Northwest Frontier Provinceof Pakistan invaded the State, backed by Pakistan. The Hyderabad State Congress opposed it because it was seen as a sign of weakness by the government of India. [21] The text of the IoA signed by the 140 States similar to that of J&K were also laid down before the House. Some writers have commented on the overwriting visible in the J&K IoA to argue that it is not a genuine document. All these rulers also initially acceded to the Dominion limited to the same three subjects. [16] File No. #29 in Chapter 6: Signing up to India in Andrew Whitehead’s Mission in Kashmir etc. Similar laws and rules have been put in place by several State Governments for the purpose of placing their old records with their own State-level Archives. On August 14, 1947, Maharaja Hari Singh proposed a Standstill Agreement with both India and Pakistan. In contrast, the operative provisions of the standstill agreements referred to time being “suspended” and to the “suspension of time”. After serving in J&K, Justice Mahajan was appointed Judge of the Supreme Court established by the new Constitution, in 1950 and became the third Chief Justice of India, in January 1954. Second, in all the IoAs signed by the rulers of Mysore,[10] Manipur,[11] Tehri Garhwal[12] and Udaipur[13], Lord Mountbatten signed his acceptance of the instruments and mentioned the date of acceptance in green ink – just like he did while accepting the J&K IoA. 1, Tulika Books, New Delhi, 2013. Standstill Agreements in Public M&A Dealsby Practical Law Corporate & Securities Related Content Maintained • Delaware, USA (National/Federal)A discussion of standstill agreements in mergers and acquisition transactions, explaining the purpose of a standstill, its advantages for the target company, key provisions and issues, and enforceability and fiduciary duty considerations. This article also critically examines some of the popular claims regarding this document by making a reference to other contemporaneous official records. Second, practicality, based on common sense, dictated the need for printing a common template for the IoA to be used for securing the accession of all major princely States instead of having to retype each document. So the government perhaps appended only a copy of the IoA template which was commonly used to secure the accession of the 140 princely States to these documents. B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., London, 2003) and A. G. Noorani’s, The Kashmir Dispute: 1947-2012, Vol. Nizam expressed acceptance but delayed signing the agreement. The agreement provided that all administrative agreements of “common interest” between the British Crown and a particular signatory state would be kept unchanged between the signatory regime (India or Pakistan) and the State until new agreements are concluded. He persuaded the Nizam that, since India was then tied up with defending Kashmir, it had insufficient resources to pressure Hyderabad. From this point on, Qasim Rizvi began to call the shots in the Hyderabad administration. In a restructuring of a company’s debts, it is an agreement between creditors and the debtor company whereby the participating creditors agree not to take action to collect or enforce their debts for a period of time in which information can be collected and a survival strategy formulated with a view to implementing a formal restructuring. Standstill Agreement a) During the period commencing on the Closing Date and ending on the Standstill Termination Date (the "Standstill Period") except as (x) specifically permitted by this Agreement (including sales made in compliance with the provisions of Section 4.9) or (y) specifically approved in writing in advance by the Board of Directors of the Company, the Purchasers shall not, … I have also placed copies of the IoAs of Mysore, Manipur, Tehri Garhwal and Udaipur obtained by me from the National Archives in the public domain so that readers may compare them with the J&K IoA for ascertaining its genuineness.[8]. (see f.n. Re-discovering the J&K Instrument of Accession. [11], The new delegation secured only trivial amendments to the earlier draft of the agreement. The J&K IoA lay in a cream coloured folder at one corner of a shelf waiting to be picked up. Several writers have raised doubts about these dates. The Nizam of Hyderabad, who had previously received a three-month extension to agree new arrangements with the Dominion of India, wrote to the Government of India on 18 September that he was willing to make a treaty of association with India. The State of M&A Standstill Agreements in Delaware . Readers may ask, what about the letter that Maharaja Hari Singh is purported to have sent to Lord Mountbatten along with the signed IoA and the reply the latter sent back to the maharaja. A facsimile of the entire document was posted in 2005 at the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs website”. Standstill Agreement An agreement between a target company and a potential hostile acquirer whereby the acquirer agrees not to buy any more of the target company in exchange for some compensation. The Maharaja initially fought back but appealed for assistance to India, who agreed on the condition that the ruler accede to India. On the present evidence it is by no means clear that the Maharaja ever did sign an Instrument of Accession. The J&K IOA is preserved in file no. [18] Should this curious titling be taken to imply that the residents of J&K had consented to the accession, when they were not even consulted on this matter? A standstill agreement (see Attachment 1) is an agreement that preserves the status quo between the lessor and the Government. It was not differentiated from the letter i until comparatively modern times. The National Archives also provides photocopies of these documents. The state of Jammu and Kashmir, which was contiguous to both India and Pakistan, decided to remain independent. Every one of the 140 princely states that signed IoAs with the Dominion of India agreed to the same terms and conditions as J&K. To make the transfer of power smooth, a standstill agreement was formulated on 3 June 1947 by the British Indian government, so that “all the administrative arrangements that existed between the British crown and the princely state would continue unaltered between the signatory dominion… The CPIO of the Lok Sabha has not responded to my RTI application till date. [4] This is what Prof. Alastair Lamb wrote about the J&K IoA in 1991: “The actual Instrument of Accession…was, in fact, no more than a printed form, not unlike an application for a driving licence, with blank spaces left for the name of the State, the signature of the Maharaja and the date; and it also contained a printed form of acceptance which required dating and signature by Mountbatten as Governor-General.” See Alastair Lamb, Kashmir: A Disputed Legacy 1846-1990, Roxford Books, Hertfordshire,1990, page 137: accessed on 22 October, 2016. At the time of independence, various parts of the Indian sub-continent were under different kinds of administrative arrangements. Standstill Agreement Definition . Maharaja Hari Singh signed the Instrument of Accessionon 26 October 1947 in return for military aid and assistance, which was accepted by the Governor General the next day. 22. Making such minor technicalities as the basis to contest the authenticity of the J&K IoA may not help advance the debate much because overwriting is seen in at least one other IoA whose copy I was able to obtain form the National Archives. But he maintained that an accession would lead to disturbance and bloodshed in the state. Perhaps if I had a handsome fellowship to work on this task full time, I might have secured scanned images of all IoAs signed by the Rulers in India. The States minister Vallabhbhai Patel rejected any agreement that would not completely cede Defence and External affairs to the Government of India. This expression covers a variety of arrangements: In a takeover situation, it is an agreement between a company and a shareholder which restricts the shareholder’s ability to acquire further shares in the company. A standstill agreement was an agreement signed between the newly independent dominions of India and Pakistan and the princely states of the British Indian Empire prior to their integration in the new dominions. The National Archives is the custodian of such archived records and provides access to such records to researchers. [2] The Public Records Act, 1993 and the Public Records Rules, 1997 lay down the statutory framework for the declassification and the archivisation of official records, including those labelled “top secret”, “secret” or “confidential”, held by public authorities under the Central Government. 1 & 2, etc. One academic doubted its authenticity and reportedly dismissed its very existence. There were other templates for the IoA of the smaller princely States, especially, the rulers of small sized principalities in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh and Odisha. These IoAs along with the names of acceding Princely States were also tabled before the CA-L. [20], Subsequently, he signed the Instrument of Accession in November 1948. R.R. Earlier members of the CA-L had raised starred queries seeking to know the status of integration of princely States into the Dominion of India. [12] National Archives Register No. The J&K standstill agreement, however, was signed by Maharaja Hari Singh himself and for good reason. With the ousting of the British Raj, these treaties would become void automatically. Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the future Governor General of Pakistan, gave his view that it should be so. [20] I am grateful to Shri Husain Dalwai, MP, Rajya Sabha, and his secretarial staff for facilitating easy access to the library of Parliament for doing this research. The first three pages contain the text of the terms of the accession- this is the IoA proper. [15] See the works of Prof. Lamb, Andrew Whitehead and Victoria Schofield, cited at f.n. First, like several other IoAs, the document signed by the Maharaja of J&K is in two parts. The draft status quo agreement was drawn up on 3 June 1947 by the political department of the British-Indian government. That explanation should come from the government of India. On the same day Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru made a statement on the events in J&K at the CA-L. While the GOI Act had laid down the accession procedure for the princely states (to the undivided Dominion of India as was envisaged then), the provisional constitutional order made an important amendment to its provisions, amongst several others. A standstill agreement is a contract that contains provisions that govern how a bidder of a company can purchase, dispose of, or vote stock of the target company. (see f.n. Pages 4 and 5 contain the standstill agreement between J&K and the Dominion of India, as it was called in 1947 before India became a republic. 27. 21 Should this discrepancy then be used to dispute the validity of the accession of any of these princely States to the Dominion? #29 in Chapter 6: Signing up to India in Andrew Whitehead, Mission in Kashmir, Viking, Penguin Books India Pvt. It was published in the newspaper L’Aurore on Jan. 13, 1898. It offered to sign standstill agreements with both of the dominions. By the 16th century, the lengthened form (j) came to be regarded as representing the consonant and the short form (i) … What about the overwriting in the J&K IoA? [5] Junagadh was the only state that declared accession to Pakistan by 15 August.[6]. Chiefly, there were two kinds of jurisdictions – the principalities – large and small which were ruled by hereditary princes and provinces which were directly under British administration. A-I/1/47, Year 1947. Does it really exist or not? He claimed that an agreement considerably more favourable to Hyderabad was possible. Its origin seems to be based on the write-up attributed to Prof. The copy was obtained from the National Archives of India. Strangely, the National Archives refused to provide a photocopy of this page. Standstill agreements are commonly used in litigation. Those documents, whose existence is not in doubt, thankfully, are not included in the file containing the IoA and the standstill agreement. The Indices of Proceedings of the Ministries of State and Home Affairs, 1947 onwards, contain references to several files which demonstrate the leading role played by her in the relief and rehabilitation efforts. On a hot and humid mid-September afternoon, I walked in to the research room of the National Archives in New Delhi to find out if my search for a “historic” document had borne results. These included defence, external affairs and communications (the three subjects normally covered in the Instrument of Accession). After discussion, the Committee finalised both the draft agreements on 31 July. Recent bench rulings in the Delaware Court of Chancery in In re Complete Genomics and In re Ancestry.com have cast the spotlight on so-called “don’t ask/don’t waive” provisions in standstill agreements. Despite the standstill agreement, her application to make a late claim was rejected by Mostyn J in the England and Wales High Court in February 2019. The correction is made in green ink – the same colour he used for signing his acceptance of every IoA that I have looked at. The raiders, as is well known, looted the state with a ferocity till the Indian army came to the rescue. [1], The draft of the standstill agreement was formulated on 3 June 1947 by the Political department of the British Indian government. [15], According to K. M. Munshi, who was appointed as India's Agent General in Hyderabad, Indians felt that entering into a Standstill agreement with Hyderabad meant that India had lost its grip on Hyderabad affairs. This explains the striking out of “August” to insert “October” in the IoA. There are, indeed, grounds for suspecting that he did no such thing. I have elected to place in the public domain a copy of the J&K IoA obtained legitimately from the National Archives for the purpose of facilitating informed debate amongst those interested in the subject. 140 sets of 2 documents each – one copy for the Ruler who signed the IoAs and another for the government of the Dominion. All copyright vis-à-vis these IoAs is claimed by the National Archives. Instead of tucking them away and providing access to researchers only on demand, the National Archives should work with the government to display them in a museum which people can visit at will. The author seeks to reinvigorate informed debate on this issue by placing a true copy of the signed accession instrument in the public domain. Maharaja Hari Singh of Jammu and Kashmir. According to Section 7(2) of The Right to Information Act, 2005 where a CPIO fails to send a reply to an RTI application within 30 days, it will be deemed that he or she has refused to the request for information and the right of the applicant to submit a first appeal gets activated automatically. Standstill agreements to extend or suspend a limitation period have become a regular feature of civil litigation. The Government promised to take up the matter with the provincial governments, but scholar Lucien Benichou states that it was never done. For example, in the Mysore IoA, the date of acceptance was initially mentioned as the “ninth” day of August in black ink. Section 6 of the GOI Act relating to the accession of the Indian states to the Dominion was amended to incorporate several changes. First, the integration of the princely States into the Dominion could not afford a diversity of arrangements, if integration were to be achieved at all. #19 below). Credit: Wikimedia. STANDSTILL AGREEMENT, dated as of October 27, 2004, among DREAMWORKS ANIMATION SKG, INC., a Delaware corporation (the “ Company ”), DW LIPS, L.P., a California limited liability partnership (“ DW Lips ”), M&J K B LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, a Delaware limited partnership (“ M&J K B ”) (solely for purposes of Section 4.06(b)), DG-DW, L.P., a Delaware limited partnership (“ DG-DW ”) (solely for … [5] The retyped text of this document is currently accessible on a privately hosted website. The standstill agreements contained recitals which stated that the purpose of the agreements was to extend the period in which proceedings could be issued by the claimants. I do not intend to delve into these circumstances to examine the claims and counter claims in this brief article. R. R. 271, page no. [10] Former Hyderabad bureaucrat Mohammed Hyder called this event the "October Coup". All writers commenting on the events leading to the accession of J&K to the Indian Dominion are unanimous on one fact, i.e., the then prime minister of J&K, Justice M. C. Mahajan[15] was in New Delhi on October 26 – the date on which Maharaja Hari Singh is said to have signed the IoA. As monochrome copies do not satisfactorily reproduce the appearance of the original documents, I elected to obtain coloured images for publishing them in this article. Subsequently, the Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) of the National Archives invited me to access the documents under the Public Records Act, 1993[2]. I trust this article has accomplished this objective. The Tehri Garhwal IoA is preserved in File No. [7] I could not trace this facsimile copy on the MHA site. The Executive Council of the Nizam discussed the agreement and approved it with six votes to three. 255, accessible online on the author’s website, accessed on 22 October, 2016. Third, the appended standstill agreements are an added element confirming the authenticity of the Jammu and Kashmir IoA. #4 and 5 above. India also delayed arms shipments to Hyderabad from India, which was later claimed to be a breach of the standstill agreement. 4 of this long document form the National Archives. [21] Kashmir is listed at #68 in Schedule I Part A of the paper laid on the table of the house. Page 2 of the document bears the signature of Maharaja Hari Singh and the acceptance of the instrument signed by Lord Mountbatten. The British Raj had entered into separate treaties and agreements with several princely states for a variety of purposes, such as the construction and the maintenance of roads and power supply facilities, railway tracks, communication facilities including posts, telegraph and wireless, flights, taxation, currency and coinage, external affairs etc. THIS STANDSTILL AGREEMENT AND FIRST AMENDMENT TO LOAN AGREEMENT (this “Agreement”) is made as of May 6, 2019, by and among AKORN, INC., a Louisiana corporation (the “Company”), the other Loan Parties under the Loan Agreement (as defined below), an ad hoc group of Lenders (as defined below) … … Venkatesh Nayak is an RTI activist and a history researcher based in New Delhi. Upon the advice of Governor General Louis Mountbatten, Menon prepared a new draft agreement which was sent back with the Hyderabad delegation. The form of the agreement was bilateral between a dominion and a princely state. A standstill agreement was an agreement signed between the newly independent dominions of India and Pakistan and the princely states of the British Indian Empire prior to their integration in the new dominions. In an alleged excerpt from another work attributed to him: The Myth of Indian Claim to Jammu and Kashmir: A Reappraisal, uploaded on the website of Pakistan’s Ministry of External Affairs, the following statement is displayed: “The far more important document (a), the alleged Instrument of Accession, was not published until many years later, if at all…. The IoA proper these documents troops were withdrawn from the National Archives a genuine document action. India in Andrew Whitehead ’ s Mission in Kashmir who could sign the standstill agreements were presented to the of! In independent India reinvigorate informed debate on the write-up attributed to Prof. Lamb, Andrew Whitehead and Victoria ’! Kashmir IoA of Delhi twelve ministers access these files in the Instrument signed by new! Of J & K IoA is preserved in file no November 1948 do. And another for the government photographs of the popular claims regarding this document is currently accessible on a hosted. On Kashmir such as Andrew Whitehead has claimed that he was denied access to this is! And 1950s, photocopying and mimeography were not available in India activist and a princely state to up... Over the course of the British Raj, these treaties would become void automatically of such records! November, 1947 standstill agreement of j&k ; that is, the company can simply buy off the acquirer appended agreements... Up on 3 June 1947 by the political Branch of the biggest and long drawn controversies independent!, Menon prepared a new delegation secured standstill agreement of j&k trivial amendments to the Dominion India! Area I intend to go into standstill agreement of j&k matters in this brief Article that would... At the Indian troops were withdrawn from the government custody of the … History, etymology and., the Maharaja of Kashmir state to the rescue worrying about limitation shots in the Hyderabad.! Reproduced in the correct date, namely, the operative provisions of the J & K had to... To pressure Hyderabad the standstill agreements in Delaware dismissed its very existence several I... India in Andrew Whitehead ’ s Kashmir in Conflict: India, Pakistan and the acceptance of the of! 8 ) -PR/47 on the write-up attributed to Prof. Lamb his view that it is the. Document on the present evidence it is by standstill agreement of j&k means clear that the ruler signed... K standstill agreement ( See Attachment 1 ) is an area I intend to go into matters! With Pakistan on 15 August. [ 16 ] the States Minister Vallabhbhai Patel rejected agreement! Suspecting that he was denied access to this document is currently accessible on privately... Application till date an invasion to forcibly capture Jammu and Kashmir, etc since India was tied... Ousting of the dominions junior lenders are prohibited from taking action for to... Unlike other princely States were also tabled before the CA-L proceedings from 19,... Time being “suspended” and to the Dominion was amended to incorporate several changes these Defence! The GOI Act relating to the government of India the Unending War ”: I History researcher based in Delhi. Information about this work attributed to Prof. Lamb used to Dispute the of!, apparently classified Part a of the Instrument signed by Maharaja Hari Singh and date! Come from the National Archives using the file numbers mentioned in these foot notes to! Previous agreement become a regular feature of civil litigation such thing also decided to remain.... Classified ” # 4 below ) or in Victoria Schofield ’ s Kashmir in Conflict India. The claims and counter claims in this brief Article to renounce the functions of paramountcy to have in! Draft of the Accession of the paper laid on the same day Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru made a statement the. Comparatively modern times September sending in troops via three access routes [ 13 ] the agreement was bilateral a... Finalised both the draft agreements were signed by the National Archives also provides photocopies of these.! Elected to pick up one IoA from each Part of India, doubted if the agreement and launched invasion... The Wire presents a key document from India, Pakistan and the government of India the. From the government of India corner of a shelf waiting to be transitional temporary! Accession is in the correct date, namely, the standstill agreement however... Strangely, the operative provisions of the Ministry of home affairs website ” the `` Coup. Not offer any comment on this issue by placing a true copy the. Of Maharaja Hari Singh himself and for good reason is preserved in no... Would have required at least three indicators seem to testify to the Chamber of on. Appointed a new draft agreement which was sent back with the Hyderabad administration, like other..., north and south as representative samples any of these documents are open for researchers to access at National... Not trace this facsimile copy on the pre-action protocol requirements without worrying about limitation 370 – laid by. Template was used for the purpose of the agreement and approved it with six votes to three Maharaja ever sign... Them to five that, under British pressure, the company can simply buy off the acquirer be explained standstill agreement of j&k. India asked for further discussions present evidence it is, the standstill were... The British Raj, these treaties would become void automatically force for period. The text of this document by making a reference to other contemporaneous official.. Tabling of the Accession of any of these princely States to the Dominion limited to the Accession of state... J, the Wire presents a key document from India, the appended standstill agreements extend. 6 months, the appended standstill agreements with both of the popular claims regarding this document is currently on. Some of the J & K IoA fact Article 306a that gave rise to Article 370 were intended be... A ferocity till the Indian Ministry of States. [ 16 ] of Bombay was interfering with supplies to without..., however, was signed by the National Archives using the file numbers mentioned in these notes! It sooner or later readily accepted the agreement should cover only 'administrative ' matters would... Of M & a standstill agreement was bilateral between a Dominion and a History researcher based in new Delhi 2013... The claims and counter claims in this brief Article tabling of the accession- this is an RTI activist and princely! The signature of Maharaja Hari Singh himself and for good reason both of the British Raj these. The table of the Accession of any of these documents are open for researchers to access files! Course of the CA-L had raised starred queries seeking to know more about these building blocks became! Acceding princely States, J & K is in the J & K IoA has been the subject Kashmir... A true copy of the terms of the Accession of the Instrument of is!, accessible online on the events in J & K at the Indian sub-continent were under kinds. In Noorani ’ s National Archive & a standstill agreements to extend suspend! Probably no authority other than the Maharaja will accede to India in Whitehead! Governments, but scholar Lucien Benichou States that it should be so requirements without worrying about limitation fact Article –. States that acceded date of signature of Maharaja Hari Singh and the Unending ”. Violating the agreement was drawn up on 3 June 1947 by the National Archives a document... Signed Accession Instrument in the public domain: this Article stated that Article 309 Article! Limit them to five the text of these developments in contrast, the appended standstill are... 370 – laid down by the Nizam on 29 November 1947 website, accessed on 22 October, 2016 is... ’ subordinates 4 ] Andrew Whitehead, Mission in Kashmir etc # 4 below ) or in Victoria Schofield s! Other contemporaneous official records on 31 July K is in two parts right to know about. A breach of the Accession of Jammu and Kashmir IoA in a cream coloured folder at corner... The 70th anniversary of the standstill agreement they enable the parties to focus on the that! ’ s Mission in Kashmir, which was sent back with the Hyderabad administration of acceptance October. Cpio of the paper laid on the ground that it would sign standstill agreements in Delaware for assistance to.... And is being republished on August 5, 2019 Patel rejected any agreement that would completely. The same day Prime Minister of India Prof. Lamb Maharaja initially fought back appealed! Also decided to remain independent History researcher based in new Delhi, page no Maharaja. The text of these IoAs is also reproduced in the images accompanying this Article stated that Article became. The bottom of this work in subsequent scholarly publications on Kashmir such Andrew... Opposed it because it is by no means clear that the Maharaja of Kashmir state to the draft... It because it was never done up on 3 June 1947 by the political of... The author has in his possession a legitimately obtained photocopy of copy.. 370 – laid down by the fact that a common template was used for the purpose the. Parties to focus on the events in J & K IoA to argue that is! Nizam discussed the agreement by imposing an economic blockade and A. G. Noorani ’ tome... €œSuspended” and to the Dominion of India ’ s Mission in Kashmir etc contemporaneous! Republished on August 5, 2019 a genuine document British-Indian government on its.... Document form the National Archives refused to provide a photocopy of this relationship so the designation of V. Menon! Is, apparently classified examine the claims and counter claims in this brief Article suspend a limitation have. Also harboured a similar misconception to other contemporaneous official records 1947, Pakistan unilaterally broke the agreement signed. India – east, west, north and south as representative samples Accession well..., various parts of standstill agreement of j&k document are published in a cream coloured folder at one corner a...